Can virtual reality help tackle football’s heading-related dementia crisis?

Photo of author
Written By Chris

It’s a reality, universally acknowledged, that soccer has been appallingly sluggish at confronting the terrifying actuality that heading may very well be killing generations of gamers.

Some consultants are imploring the sport’s powers-that-be to ban heading given mounting proof that it may trigger dementia – a transfer GOAL vigorously backed 5 years in the past.

However there isn’t any signal that this may occur imminently, so may digital actuality (VR) assist in the interim?

Scientists at Manchester Metropolitan College’s Institute of Sport are trialling Participant 22, a brand new VR platform, which is designed to coach footballers to move a ball with out exposing them to the potential risks of doing so.

Participant 22, created by the Manchester-based cognitive growth and evaluation firm Rezzil, includes customers carrying a pair of VR goggles whereas enterprise a set of digital duties aimed toward enhancing their footballing abilities.

Fairly than heading an precise ball, gamers head a digital one.

Andy Etches, co-founder of Rezzil, advised GOAL: “There’s an apparent profit to decreasing the variety of instances a participant heads the ball in apply.

“That is particularly necessary in younger gamers, as acknowledged by current rule adjustments at federations internationally.

“Rezzil may help be sure that gamers are nonetheless in a position to apply and develop the ability of heading in a non-contact means.

“We’re mid-way via a physique of analysis that will hyperlink the 2 collectively, nevertheless it’s affordable to imagine that we may help right here.”



VR’s intervention seems essential in mild of the rising fears among the many medical group that heading can have deadly penalties.

Former skilled gamers are over three and a half instances extra more likely to die attributable to dementia, and over 5 instances extra more likely to die attributable to Alzheimer’s illness than the overall inhabitants, based on a landmark examine printed within the journal JAMA Neurology final 12 months.

The College of Glasgow’s Dr Willie Stewart, who led the Soccer’s InfluencE on Lifelong well being and Dementia threat (FIELD) analysis, advised The Guardian: “With the present information, we’re now on the level to recommend that soccer needs to be offered with a well being warning saying repeated heading in soccer might result in an elevated threat of dementia.”

Dr Stewart’s stark revelation will need to have come as a crushing blow to the burgeoning variety of footballers and their households who’ve suffered from this savage and cruel illness.

It is going to be 20 years in November because the former West Brom and England striker, Jeff Astle, grew to become the primary British footballer to have been dominated by an inquest to have died attributable to power traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a sort of dementia.

Within the case of Astle, who was simply 59 when he died, the low-level mind trauma was proved to have developed from the repeated heading of footballs.

5 of England’s 1966 World Cup-winning workforce — Ray Wilson, Martin Peters, Nobby Stiles, Sir Bobby Charlton and Sir Jack Charlton — have all suffered from the degenerative illness since Astle’s demise in January 2002.

Numerous different footballers of lesser renown have additionally been troubled by the devastating situation, however the information of legendary names’ struggles seems to have jolted soccer into motion.

Jeff Astle West Brom 1970 GFX


Youngsters beneath the age of 12 in England, Scotland and Northern Eire had been in February 2020 banned from heading the ball in coaching, mirroring related strikes in international locations akin to the US.

Gary Lineker and Alan Shearer had been among the many former England gamers who launched a joint assertion final 12 months demanding that the footballing authorities urgently implement a brand new technique to sort out the game’s dementia disaster, which the “terrified” group labelled a “ticking time bomb”.

The FA, Premier League and EFL, endorsed by the gamers’ union, have since introduced tips limiting “high-impact” headers to 10 every week in coaching.

Such measures are insufficient, nonetheless, based on Dr Stewart. He stated they had been “not based mostly in science” and insisted no class of header created much less threat.

Enter VR and its a lot safer proposition.

Manchester Metropolitan College Institute of Sport researchers have been testing how efficient Participant 22 is in enhancing the heading strategy of a participant by evaluating the talents of these coaching with and with out the VR system.

Dr Greg Wooden, Senior Lecturer in Sport and Train Psychology on the Manchester Metropolitan College Institute of Sport, advised GOAL: “Analysis has proven that heading potential might mitigate the danger of subconcussive occasions in soccer gamers.

“So, we’re investigating whether or not studying to move the ball in VR improves heading potential with out exposing participant to the repetitive impacts of heading the ball.

“We’ve got three teams of college footballers participating: a management group who do no heading coaching; a VR group who prepare within the VR simulation over three 30-minute periods over 10 days; and a bodily apply group who prepare precise heading in the actual world for 3 30-minute periods over 10 days.

“We take pre- and post-measurements of heading ability within the ‘actual’ world and in addition measure perceived heading potential and confidence.

“We’re presently analysing this information and hope to have some leads to the approaching months.”



Dr Wooden is worked up to be concerned in what “may very well be a revolution in sports activities coaching”.

“For my part, digital actuality has an necessary place in elite sport,” he stated. “We simply want to seek out out the place it’s best used to have the most important impression on participant efficiency and well-being.”

After the present trial, he stated he deliberate to launch an additional examine consisting of an extended coaching interval, with extra members and “in all probability with higher gamers”.

Rezzil’s Etches is assured his expertise may very well be broadly utilized by skilled groups and academies to cut back contact time with the ball for heading apply.

He stated: “Sadly, the groups [using the technology currently] don’t enable us to make use of press statements with their names, however we work with six Premier League groups and gamers individually from throughout the EFL. We additionally work with a couple of others internationally, together with worldwide federations and league groups.

“There’s no cause why Rezzil couldn’t be used for studying set-pieces together with practising normal timing and frequent sport conditions.

“I consider it is going to change into a standard a part of coaching in any respect ranges of the sport as time goes on. We’re already working with elite groups, particular person professional gamers and grassroots gamers on this space.”

Daybreak Astle, daughter of Jeff Astle, backed Rezzil’s innovation.

Astle is main a devoted dementia division within the Skilled Footballers’ Affiliation (PFA) as a part of the union’s driver to make sure assist for former gamers with neurodegenerative illnesses is “a high precedence”.

She advised GOAL: “I believe something we will do to cut back this horrendous elevated threat of neurodegenerative illnesses in our footballers must be welcomed.”

Whether or not soccer must go even additional and outlaw heading altogether stays a matter of intense debate.

Dr Wooden isn’t in favour of this taking place simply but, nonetheless.

He stated: “I believe the incidence of ex-professional gamers affected by dementia may be very alarming, however I don’t suppose there’s sufficient understanding of the contribution that heading a soccer has performed on this course of to ban it utterly from the sport.

“It may very well be that developments in ball design, and possibly even a mode of play in trendy soccer that produces much less heading, may reduce the danger of illness in trendy footballers, nevertheless it’s actually tough to say.

“We definitely want extra analysis into the results of soccer heading on mind growth and performance.”

Leave a Comment